Order Options
special
Don't want to cook for the Holidays? Or your next work party? Or dinner? We can help! We offer a variety of special order menu items from our kitchen to yours! These special order options are a combination from Windfall's menu and our seasonal sister business, Apple Knockers Ice Cream Parlor's menu. Please give as much notice as possible but at minimum, 3 days. Give us a call here at Windfall, 269-475-9998 during business hours and place your orders today!
Coconut Cream Pie
Our homemade coconut cream pie is offered in an uncut 10" size.
19.95 each
Pecan Chocolate Layered Pie
Our homemade pie is layered with toasted pecans, cream cheese, chocolate filling and topped with homemade whipped cream. Available in an uncut, 10" size
19.95 each
Caramel Apple Nut Pie
This fan favorite is a classic apple pie with a twist! This uncut, 10" pie, has walnuts baked in and caramel drizzled on top for an over the top indulgence!
19.95 each
Peanut Butter Cream Pie
Our homemade peanut butter cream pie has not one, but two layers of peanut butter crumbles sandwiching vanilla cream and our homemade whipped cream. We offer this in an uncut, 10" size.
19.95 each
Raspberry Cream Pie
Our homemade raspberry cream pie is a perfect mix of tart raspberries and vanilla cream. This uncut 10" pie is also topped with our homemade whipped cream.
19.95 each
Banana Cream Pie
Our homemade banana cream pie is a vanilla cream base with a hint of Kahlua to elevate the sweet bananas. We do not use any preservatives, so the bananas may change color, however it will not affect its deliciousness! This is available in an uncut, 10" size.
19.95 each
Pecan Pie
We offer a traditional pecan pie in an uncut, 10" size. Add on a special request for our homemade whipped cream to top it off!
19.95
Pumpkin Pie
Our delicious pumpkin pie makes any meal feel like home! Add on a special request for our homemade whipped cream to make it the perfect, traditional treat! Available in an uncut 10" size.
19.95
​
Pecan Bread Pudding
Our AWARD WINNING homemade pecan bread pudding has been a fan favorite for over a decade! Available in an uncut 10 x 13 pan.
46.35
​
Spinach & Cheese Quiche
Savor the delightful flavors of our homemade Spinach and Cheese Quiche, crafted with fresh spinach, creamy Swiss cheese, and farm-fresh eggs. Available in an uncut 10" size, making it perfect for sharing at breakfast or brunch gatherings.
22.95
Bacon & Cheddar Quiche
Enjoy the delicious combination of crispy bacon and rich cheddar cheese in our homemade quiche. Available in an uncut 10" size, this dish is an ideal choice for breakfast or brunch gatherings.
22.95
Cheesy Hashbrowns
Our homemade cheesy hashbrowns make an perfect side dish for any occasion. Available in an uncut
10 x 13 pan for your convivence.
33.00
Cornbread Casserole
Available in a 10 x 13 pan, our homemade cornbread casserole is a combination of whole sweet corn and savory, buttery, goodness!
41.35
Mama's Mac & Cheese
Nothing beats homemade mac & cheese and my mama's is no different! Available in an uncut
10 x 13 pan of cheesy goodness! This fan favorite is made with 3 different kinds of cheese to make the best homecooked mac around!
57.45
Chicken Salad
Apple Knockers' FAMOUS chicken salad is available in 2 different sizes for your next party! Our savory sweet recipe contains, pecans, craisins, and some dairy. It pairs best with pita chips, wraps, croissants or just a fork!
Pint 13.75
Quart 27.50
Amish Sweet Slaw
Another family recipe, our homemade Amish sweet slaw makes the perfect side dish for something light and different. Available in 2 sizes for your convenience, take some home today!
Pint 6.25
Quart 12.50
Take & Bake Pasties
Made fresh, than frozen, our family's authentic YOOPER pasties have been a fan favorite for years! No need to thaw, pop your frozen pasties in your oven bake them yourself! Cooking instructions are included for your convenience!
Beef Pasty
Our homemade 12oz beef pasties have ground beef, seasonings, onions, potatoes, carrots and YES, rutabaga!
9.00 each
Chicken Pasty
Our homemade chicken pasty contains, all white meat chicken, seasonings, potatoes, broccoli, onion, carrot, and YES rutabaga!
9.00 each
Ketchup OR Gravy?
The debate continues! Which do your prefer on your pasty, ketchup or gravy? You decide!